MAC Sublime Culture is a creamy, highly pigmented, retractable lip liner in a pink/caramel hue that. It’s available on Amazon.
The Dupes
ColourPop Lip Pencil ‘Oh Snap’ ($6)
Buy at AMAZON/COLOURPOP/ULTA.
True Fiction Lip Liner ‘LP04 Nude’ ($4)
Buy at TRUEFICTION (Save 10% off True Fiction with code: allintheblush)